Chapter 17 of Michael Pollan’s Omnivore’s Dilemma attempts to use the gross-out technique throughout the chapter. It begins with Pollan sitting at the Palms restaurant eating a steak as he reads Peter Singer” Animal Liberation. The book does enough work on Pollan to turn him temporarily vegetarian. The chapter then moves in to discuss the rights of animals. Should animals have equal rights to those as humans, was the central question for debate. This gives the reader a chance to dive into the mind of Singer as Pollan gives hypothetical questions that many would ask a vegetarian and answers them via Singer’s writing. From here, we get a deeper look into the vegetarian perspective and the choices that they have to make when choosing food. The main indicator for what is allowed primarily has to do with whether or not the animal in question suffered in the production process. It is also taken into account whether the animal was happy during its cycle through the system. If the animal did not suffer, would it be justified to eat it? The questions surrounding suffering and happiness are difficult because in the end, who knows what the animals are actually thinking. Pollan does give some counter argument describing that even if all animal production ceased, that everyone became vegan; there would not necessarily be any change in animals dying. Pollan finishes the chapter by going through the killing process for a steer on the kill floor. From the sounds of it, the process does not seem very attractive, even if the cow is dead from the start.
Some people may be affected by reading books like these that try to describe what happens to animals that are used for food production, but frankly, I have found it repetitive and annoying. I don’t plan on changing the way I eat and I don’t try to convince others to change either. So when someone gives me a dirty look or some random fact or statistic about the steak I ordered, frustration and utter bitterness towards this interruptive individual set in. Honestly, I love a good steak and the only way to get one is for something to die. I’m not sure there is a more humane way of slaughtering an animal, but f there is I would completely support it. But do I plan on changing what I like to eat? Hell no.
Need a moment? Think it over with a thought:
Need a moment? Think it over with a thought:
1. If the animal did not suffer, would it be justified to eat it?
2. How do chapter 17 and its message affect you?
3. How does it make you feel when someone tells you how to eat?