Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Meat War


            Chapter 17 of Michael Pollan’s Omnivore’s Dilemma attempts to use the gross-out technique throughout the chapter.  It begins with Pollan sitting at the Palms restaurant eating a steak as he reads Peter Singer” Animal Liberation.  The book does enough work on Pollan to turn him temporarily vegetarian.  The chapter then moves in to discuss the rights of animals.  Should animals have equal rights to those as humans, was the central question for debate.  This gives the reader a chance to dive into the mind of Singer as Pollan gives hypothetical questions that many would ask a vegetarian and answers them via Singer’s writing.  From here, we get a deeper look into the vegetarian perspective and the choices that they have to make when choosing food.  The main indicator for what is allowed primarily has to do with whether or not the animal in question suffered in the production process.  It is also taken into account whether the animal was happy during its cycle through the system.  If the animal did not suffer, would it be justified to eat it?  The questions surrounding suffering and happiness are difficult because in the end, who knows what the animals are actually thinking.  Pollan does give some counter argument describing that even if all animal production ceased, that everyone became vegan; there would not necessarily be any change in animals dying.  Pollan finishes the chapter by going through the killing process for a steer on the kill floor.  From the sounds of it, the process does not seem very attractive, even if the cow is dead from the start.
            Some people may be affected by reading books like these that try to describe what happens to animals that are used for food production, but frankly, I have found it repetitive and annoying.  I don’t plan on changing the way I eat and I don’t try to convince others to change either.  So when someone gives me a dirty look or some random fact or statistic about the steak I ordered, frustration and utter bitterness towards this interruptive individual set in.  Honestly, I love a good steak and the only way to get one is for something to die.  I’m not sure there is a more humane way of slaughtering an animal, but f there is I would completely support it.  But do I plan on changing what I like to eat?  Hell no.

Need a moment?  Think it over with a thought:

1.     If the animal did not suffer, would it be justified to eat it? 

2.     How do chapter 17 and its message affect you?

3.     How does it make you feel when someone tells you how to eat?

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Circle of Life


Chapter 11 of Omnivore’s Dilemma deals with the circular model of the cow and chicken cycle.  Basically, the chapter begins with what first sounds like an awful day for the chickens.  They’re cooped (literally) in a ten-by-twelve two-foot-tall cage with 69 friends.  Not exactly the prime real estate.  But the nature of the cage change when perspective is given to it.  Turns out, the chickens actually fertilize the grass by defecating on it.  From here, the grass grows tall for the cows to eat.  As the cows lay waste behind them, the chickens in this cage are dragged by the ‘eggmobile’ across all of the cow pies.  The chickens use the cow pies as a source of protein by eating the fly larvae within them.  This high source of protein allows for a richer taste in their eggs that are taken by the farmer. Once the chickens are driven across these eaten patches of land, they are re-fertilizing it by replacing the nitrogen the soil needs to metabolize.  This process is safe, clean, and inexpensive.  It is meant to show a counter technique to big corporations and their mechanized techniques.  The most impressive aspect of this technique is that it is actually efficient.
            It is good to see that there are still farmers who choose a more natural way of producing cows and eggs.  I really like how the science behind this technique works and that it is really a never-ending cycle.  As long as both the chickens and cows eat, survive, and lay waste, then there should be no reason as to why the system can’t be continued.  Though it may not be as efficient or productive as a factory style of raising these animals, it is most definitely a more humane way to do so.  Also, it gives more ease to know that the food you’ll be eating is less ‘genetically modified.’


Got a moment?  Think it over with a thought:

1.     Do you believe that such a process could be used widespread?  Or would it not be able to keep up with demand?
2.     How could farmers for big corporations learn from this?  How could the corporations learn form this?

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Food Review


            Entertainment weekly is not a political magazine, it gives articles straightforward from what they view.  From this review, it seemed like the author truly felt that this film was successful in its attempt to produce a documentary that could inform those unknown to the current food industry situations.  The reviewer probably didn’t know much about what the film was speaking out prior to seeing the film so the film must have had a strong affect on his views.  Because of this affect, he gave the film a good review for its proper informative strategies that worked.  He believes that director Robert Kenner “connected the dots” with the between all the questions about where food comes from, how it is made, and what is at cost for doing so.


            This review makes a point that the film does use the usual gross-out tactics that many documentaries trying to make a point exploit.  However, it should be taken into account that this reviewer works for a conservative newspaper so it can be seen that its bias would be to go against what the film was trying to do.  This reviewer would rather keep the status quo more than the usual person.  It also seemed that from the tone of the review, the author didn’t want to spend much time on the article.  It felt like he was just going through the motions of getting out a review.


            This review seems to be more on a neutral level.  The reviewer touches on a few of the general ideas detailed in the film and some of the ironies that contributed to the impact of the film.  I do agree that this film is very helpful for the newcomer to the subject because I knew almost nothing about what was happening with the food industry.  But after watching this film, I definitely can say that I know more about it than ever.  The author of this article clearly states that this film isn’t one of the most influential films of its subject matter, but it did carry some weight with the constant shock images shown throughout the film.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

The Corn and the Cow


In chapter 4 of Omnivore’s Dilemma, we go through the different segments of the life of a cow from birth to slaughter.  It begins with of course the food that is fed to the cows: corn.  Science proves that by feeding cows a corn based diet, they rate of weight gain cuts the time to slaughter down from years to months.  But before all of this, the cows go through a process called weaning.  Weaning is when calves are separated from their mother at the point in time when they are able to feed and walk on their own.  This also prepares the calves for the feedlot.  The chapter then goes into the science of the corn feed and the dangers it brings to the cattle.  Because the cows are evolutionally not made to eat corn, it is extremely rich and sensitive to their body’s development.   But because the price of corn is so cheap and the results of it are satisfying, farmers will continue to use corn as their base for feed to cows.  The history behind why other sources of feed are given as well, for example, feeding cows parts of other cows.  However, this didn’t prove to last long because it was later found out that it was the cause of mad cow disease.  This though then brought up the argument that feeding other animals, such as pigs, bovine meat, then feeding cows the meat of those dead pigs that the cow meat would be passed along to the cow through the pig causing mad cow disease to reoccur.  This chapter brings into question the integrity of how the cows are fed and what that might mean for what we as humans are eating.
            I found this chapter to be very interesting, especially in the different precautions taken for having to feed the cows corn.  I didn’t realize that there were starch balances or certain trainings for cows to go through in order to be properly matriculated into eating a calorie source that isn’t natural for them.  It is also sad that the feedlot cows are forced to eat to death, literally.  They eat to get big and are then slaughtered, and that’s if the diet itself doesn’t kill them.  According to the book, almost 1/3 of the cows have infected livers due to bacteria entering into the bloodstream because the stomach lining has been worn down.  Overall, it is really just sad to read that this is how the food we eat comes to be.

Need a moment?  Think it over with a thought:

1.     If you had the choice right now of buying meat that was raised in the way described in the book at one price vs. meat that was raised naturally off eating grass at a higher price, which would you choose?

2.     Having cows on this diet of cheap corn keeps the price of meat at a reasonable level.  Would it be safe to just turn the feedlot off and make cattle free range again?  How would this affect the prices and the economy?

A Food Inc. Production


Food Inc., a film directed to exploit the problems of America’s obsession over food and food production.  The film explores the entire process of where food comes from.  In Robert Kenner’s mind, the process begins with corn.  Corn is in almost all food, but it also has become the main nutrition base for feeding livestock.  From there, the film dives into the process of getting an animal ready for slaughter by examining the period of which it takes to get that animal to the proper weight.  This, as the film shows, has become a process that is extremely filthy, dangerous, and unhealthy to the livestock.  It also shows how new food born illnesses have come about such as the new strain of E. Coli.  The film then tries to go to the farmers themselves and question why they choose to treat the animals this way.  The answer is plain and simple: money.  However, this answer is understandable among the farmers because it seems that they never get out of any debt, thus they become slaves to the corporations they have contracts with.  Yet, none of the corporations were will to interview for the film to comment.  It appears that corporations are exploiting the laws and subsidies in the industry to get as much of the market as possible.  This monopolization of the industry has done nothing but hurt those who labor in it.
            The film definitely made its point that there are serious problem in the food industry.  One of the biggest problems is that consumer knowledge is lacking extremely.  Consumers don’t try to change anything in the industry because they simply don’t know what is going on.  Maybe if they did, there might be a higher uproar as to what is going on and what is going to be done about it.  That is exactly what this film is trying to do with several tactics.  It seems that it first tried to draw the audience in with a few ‘wow’ facts such as those about corn.  Then the numbers and stats come into play.  About ¾ of the way through, the treatment of the animals is shown to really break the barrier.  By starting small and  building up the intensity, the film is successful in continually keeping the viewer interested and thinking throughout the film.

Need a moment?  Think it over with a thought:

1.     Do you see any change in the way things are done both in the corporate and farming worlds of the food industry?

2.     Do you believe that by making a film like this, it will be enough to actually cause people to stand up and say something or is it just going to be another informational but unimportant escape?

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

This Book May Know A Thing Or Two...


After reading the first three chapters of The Omnivore’s Dilemma, it’s shocking to see how much corn is in almost everything that we eat.  Michael Pollan, the author, talks first about the wonderland of produce that lies within a grocery store.  There really is nothing like having everything to survive and then some within a short trip from one’s house.  From here, Pollan dives deeper into where all of these products come from and lands on one common denominator: corn.  This transition then brings Pollan to talk about the process the corn goes through.  Growing corn seems fairly simple, conceptually.  It’s actually a time-consuming and tedious task where focus must always be at 100%.  Weaved into this, we are given a history of how corn became the king crop that it is today.  The answer stems directly from science from what is known as the Haber-Bosch Process.  From this process, scientists were able to “fix” nitrogen from the atmosphere and convert I into being used for fertilizer.  From here, crop yield only went up.  Today, the world would not be able to survive without the Haber-Bosch Process because today’s hybrid corn seeds require an immense amount of fertilization that the classical process of using the sun could not keep up. Once the corn is made and ready to be taken to the grain elevator, the Federal Government has its few words of wisdom t share with the farmers.  The government must keep a keen eye on agribusiness to make sure prices stay stable and that farmers are subsidized for their losses.  This may include throwing away corn that could cause a drop in the market price.  It would seem that all together the life of the farmer is not the same as those fun children’s books back in elementary school.
Even in the first three chapters, it is hard not to be at least a little surprised at how much corn is used, wasted, and dictating of farmers’ lives.  It doesn’t seem like farmers have much choice in anything.  What also caught my eye was the fact that farmers are forced to work at a loss.  To be losing money everyday for hard work is baffling to me.  Yet, the bottom line is, we need these people to do this work.  Just as the book asks, whom does the farmer work for?  Himself?  Or the debt he tries to pay off for his machinery or loss in over production?  Or are they slaves to the consumer of corn products?  It seems like “all of the above” could be the best answer.

Need a moment?  Think it over with a thought:

1.     Do you agree with the way farmers have been treated?  America was built from agribusiness, yet it seems it may also be its doom.  What could be done to help with keeping a stable price that doesn’t cause farmers to be at a constant loss?

2.     As mentioned before, whom do you think the farmer works for?

3.     Should farmland be expanded to help take the pressures off of the few farmers that are left even though this may cause a drop in population and other businesses in the area?  Or should America continue on its path of high demands from a select few?